Capt. Edgar J. Steadman
Lawrence Twilley
Senator Robert Benson
Justice Potter Stewart
Grayson
Marco
Augustus
Roger Bower
Buddy Providence
Brock 'Wingman' Coxman
Charles Mangano
The Sheriff
Big John Dawson
Jake LaMotta
Fairbanks
Randolph McCluskey
Frank Stone
Doug Hermann
Uncle Costello
Mr. Smith (segment "To Hell With You")
Dr. Edward Dennehey
Himself
Captain Tom Edwards
Ret. Detective Gil Diamante
Jack Steele
Jerry
Vince the Godfather
Uncle Rip
Jim Fleming
John Wayne Gacy
Massimo
Stewart
Professor Uberoth
Silas Jansen
Alex
Ronnie White
Willy
Frank Parks
Ted
Boyle
Sheriff John Quincy Wydel
Tom Reed
George Holliday
Jacob Long
Simon
Mr. Griffith
Spyder
Bo Young
Fred Vance
Alton Owens
Ted Castle
Det. Torrance
Dean Crept
Max Fenton
Andrew LeBretian
Det. Chuck Fowler
Detective Hardcastle
Milt
Tommy Cucci
Mike Stark
Gil Meadows
Frank Rosenfeld
Lou Reilly
Mike Organski
Charles Duprey
Randall Shaye
Dooley
Hudson
Sammy Gravano
Special Agent Ernest Paxton
Johnny Rochetti
Hollan
Sid Dunleavy
William Cochran
Ray Patterson
Marcus Deerfield (segment "The Final Hour")
John Hatch
Detective Mike Stoller
Walter Hilderman
Terry Harper
Bloss
J.D.
Richie Madano
Custodian
Flattop
Mike
Prince Ippolito Polozov
Arthur Kressler
Teko
Tommy Earl Browner
Burt the Booster
Sgt. Buck Atwater
Evelle
Gene
Pigiron
Morris
Philip 'Cockeye' Stein
Pug Face Crusher
Bille
Audience Member
Captain Karlsson
