Uncle Carmine
Grandpa
Lou Branch
Captain Parker
Chief Lassiter
Danny
Shah of Iran
Giovanni
Joseph Palermo
Uncle Sam
Skippy
Vernon Scott
The Count
Father Antonio
Giuseppe LaMotta
Joe DiMaria
Frank
Chief Burton
Alexandru Damian
Chips
Jimmy Scambino
Sheriff Big Jack
Alfie
Yeshiva Principal
Bud
Big Mike
Joe Scoleri
Daniel Miller
Mayor Palantine
Red Parker
Jonathan
Himself
Tony Salerno
Himself
Santa Claus
Sheriff Roy Basehart
Roy Basehart
Rotti Largo
Catch Turner
Maitre Steinfeld
Self (archive footage)
Self (archive footage)
Wally
Charlie
Gus Panas
Self/Sergeant Phil Cerreta
Buddy Stafford
Gino Barberini
Nicola Dellarusso
Scheck (voice)
Antonio Primavera
Gallio
Laszlo Pryce
Lorenzo Mancini
Sonny Talia
Joe Maloni
Frank Rizzo
Constantine Kiamos
Fabiano Grazzi
Blackburn
Harry Johanson
Harvey
Graham Crockett
Horace Burke
CIA Deputy Director Kenny Rackmill
Guy Cipriani
Franck
Fulgencio Capulet
Lt. Gil Farrand
Piero Malacici
Delgoti
Henry Kissinger
J.J. Davis
Dr. Winslow
Captain Phil Giarusso
Ed Starling
Anthony Caruso
Tommy Morolto (uncredited)
The Tenor
Eddie Valentine
Lt. Willman
Paul Cicero
Lips Manlis
Jack Wilder
Tony Pazzo
Mike Vogel
Colonel Malcolm Grommett Spears
Reverend Penny
Himself
Harvey
Doyle Reinecker
Warden Nicholas F. Castle
Phil Romano
Carlo Danzie
Detective Pat Chambers
Walter
Louis Fraina
Capt. Edelson
Reilly
Lowell Myers
Jazz Maffie
Lou Friedlander
Chubby De Coco
Reverend Willie Williams
Lou Springer
Harry Walters
Hips
Gloucester
Curtis Mahoney
Walter Menkes
Gig's Father
Coughing Cop
Samuels
Owner of Gus & Grace's Home